Saturday, November 14, 2026
Reasons why this case may be a poor vehicle.
Given the recent string of errors by lower courts at the behest of clc, it is important that the court take case about disclaimers to clear up confusion resulting from the dicta in C U.
This is probably not that case. Plaintiffs focused on Bonta and Furgatch, to the near exclusion of the controlling cases, Talley, Barnette, Tornillo, 303, Chiles. They misunderstood C U and the key term of art, exacting scrutiny. They mislabeled disclaimers as disclosure, leading the Alaska court down the wrong trail.
In cases about disclaimers, the court has reached the right result. Talley, McIntyre, ACLF, NIFLA. But in cases about something else, that then tack on a disclaimer issue at the end, the court's opinions have been misleading and confusing. In McConnell v FEC and Citizens United, two James Bopp cases about express advocacy under Valeo, the court turned down applied challenges to disclosure, and incidentally disclaimers, without confronting the underlying unconstitutionality of the disclaimer rules, because Mr. Bopp carefully refraining from doing so, as he had in cases such as Smith v W VA, that vermont one, the wisconsin one barland, and riley v kyrtl
If a person cannot put a sign on their lawn that says Vote for Smith, there is nothing left of the First Amendment. No speech is entitled to higher protection.
I am sympathetic to those who want to challenge burdensome disclosure regimes under exacting scrutiny. But because disclaimers have a different much tighter standard, also called exacting scrutiny, it is wrong to risk over regulation of that speech by lumping them together.
Three cases heading to the Court present opportunities to reaffirm Talley and McIntyre, which remain good law, this one, the AfP v Meyer case, and Meta v Washington State. The Meta case is too big to ignore. An important free speech platform has been hit with millions in fines they do not owe, sending chilling ripples across the land.
The Meyer case, with its strong dissent by Bumtahay... may be a better vehicle. It has some of the same problems of plaintiffs and the court lumping disclosure and disclaimers together, two line s of cases separated by a common name of their different stabdards.
This court has options in how it handles this case. (explain or list the options.) Each of the amici has urged that the court grant. I am less sure.
To begin with, I encourage the court to call for the views of the solicitor general. Recently following the election there have been staff changes at the voting rights division. It is unclear to me what position the adminstration will take. It is important that someone argues for disclaimers as distinct from disclosure.
The Court can call for views of s g. It can hold for Meta or Meyer. If there are six votes, it can summarily reverse. It could gvr for reconsideration in light of Chiles or First Choice. It can grant. It could deny, as it did in Gaspee v Mederos and No on E v Chiu, which also raised these issues.
In the event of denial, a justice could make a statement, clarifying that the case was wrongly decided but did not merit review.
As in Delaware Strong, a justice could dissent, since the Alaska court erred in refusing to follow Talley v California. **what am i forgetting?